by Matteo Scaramuccia.
Hi Brandon,
it looks like you're running SCORM 2004 on a very old version of Moodle, running itself on Microsoft SQLServer.
Your issue should be addressed since 2.0 (MDL-24863) but that seems not true in your case: please, clone your production site and try to update the clone to the latest available branch version i.e. 2.0.10 (still unsupported), add there the same SCORM package and see if the error disappears.
HTH,
Matteo